Papa Carlo Pizzeria & Gelati

" We visited Papa Carlo's on a Friday night and were lucky to find a table. The ambiance is cozy with charming decorations and friendly staff. We opted for the Papa Carlo special pizza and a side of calamari. The pizza was good but I felt it lacked a bit of seasoning. The calamari, however, was fantastic! It was lightly battered and served with a delicious dipping sauce. Overall, it was nice, but I think they could elevate the flavors a bit more in their pizzas. Still, I’d be open to visiting again someday to give another dish a try. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" I finally got around to trying Papa Carlo’s after hearing so much about it. The staff were friendly when I arrived, and I appreciated their help in suggesting what to order. I settled on a pizza and it was good but slightly underwhelming compared to the raving reviews I'd read. The crust wasn't too special and the toppings could have been more generous. I enjoyed my meal but expected more. It had a nice vibe though, which made the evening pleasant overall. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Papa Carlo's has been one of my go-to spots for pizza for quite some time. Every time I visit, the service exceeds expectations, and the pizza never fails to impress. I appreciate how they use quality ingredients, resulting in some of the best flavors I can find. The atmosphere is always bustling but comfortable. Parking can be tricky, but it is worth the effort for a meal here. I always leave satisfied and looking forward to my next visit! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" I visited Papa Carlo's after seeing great reviews, but unfortunately, my experience wasn't as perfect as I'd hoped. The atmosphere was nice, but the pizza I had was average at best. The flavors weren’t bold, and I felt it could use a lot more seasoning to truly shine. The service was excellent, but they couldn’t make up for the disappointing food. I might give it another try down the road, but this first experience wasn't memorable. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" Papa Carlo's was a fantastic experience! The whole vibe felt authentic Italian, from the decor to the food. I had some friends join me, and every dish we ordered was a hit! My favorite was their 4-cheese pizza, bursting with flavor. While it might be a little more expensive than your average pizza joint, the quality and freshness make it worth the extra bucks. It’s friendly and family-oriented while also being cozy enough for date night! I highly recommend it to anyone looking for quality pizza in a charming setting. " (*Curated Review*)

×

" I stumbled upon Papa Carlo's while driving through Lockport, and I'm so glad I did! The pizza was absolutely incredible, especially the Mama Anna Deluxe. It was packed with flavor and made with fresh ingredients that truly made the difference. The crust was perfectly baked, not too thick, but substantial enough to hold everything together. The service was fast and friendly, making the experience even better. Definitely a place I'd return to again and again! My only wish is that they had a few more vegetarian options on the menu to choose from. Overall, a fantastic place for anyone who loves great pizza! " (*Curated Review*)

×

" My family tried Papa Carlo's for the first time last week, and we were blown away! We were promptly seated and the atmosphere felt friendly and warm. I decided to order the pasta and I was pleasantly surprised at how fresh it tasted. My husband stuck with pizza and claimed it was the best he’d had in a long time. The desserts looked incredible too, but we didn't save room after indulging in our meals. I highly recommend trying this spot if you're ever in the area; it’s surely worth visiting again! " (*Curated Review*)

×